You May Like
1887-90 Old Judge N172 REPRINT Jake Beckley, Pittsburgh Alleghenys (Pirates) HOF
$3.50
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Old Judge Auto Oliver Perez #OP Auto Pittsburgh Pirates
$5.58
View Details
AL MAUL, Pittsburgh Allegheny City/Pirates ~ N172 OLD JUDGE 1886-90 REPRINT
$2.75
View Details
Trey Beamon AUTOGRAPH Pittsburgh Pirates 1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge AUTO
$3.49
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Baseball Card BOB CARUTHERS Brooklyns PSA 1.5 CAREER 218-99
$1395.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Bill Farmer R/h close Pittsburgh PSA 2 BXRD 39 centered
$650.00
View Details
1887-1890 Old Judge N172 REPRINT: Art Whitney, Pittsburgh Alleghenys (Pirates)
$2.50
View Details
Jake Beckley,Pittsburgh Alleghenys,baseball,Old Judge Cigarettes,First Baseman,2
$8.99
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Baseball Card BILL BISHOP Pittsburgh PSA 2
$995.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Thomas Brown Bat in r/hand at side Pittsburg PSA 2 BXRD 95
$550.00
View Details
2005 (PIRATES) Origins Old Judge #184 Jason Bay YS
$1.69
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Otto Schomberg Hands cap high Indianapolis PSA 3 BXRD 96
$750.00
View Details
1886-87 N172 177 Old Judge Pud Galvin SGC Authentic HOF Ready to Pitch HOF
$4499.95
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #83-5 John Coleman – Bat in Right Hand at Side - PR
$330.00
View Details
Rare 1886-87 N172 177-1 Old Judge Pud Galvin SGC Authentic/Alt
$10000.00
View Details
Brian Giles 1995 T-96 Old Judge Mini Auto Autograph /6000 2885/6000
$3.49
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Old Judge Ralph Kiner #110 HOF
$3.41
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Chuck Lauer hands forward Pittsbrughs PSA 2 MK BXRD 35
$1000.00
View Details
2005 (PIRATES) Origins Old Judge #157 Oliver Perez YS
$1.69
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge **Pud GALVIN (HOF)** Baseball Card!!! Pittsburgh Allegheny's
$4500.00
View Details
1887 Gray Studio Jocko Fields Cabinet Photo Old Judge Proof Signed on Reverse
$1199.99
View Details
2005 (PIRATES) Origins Old Judge #234 Jeff Miller YS RC
$1.69
View Details
1888 N172 Old Judge Willie Kuehne #271-3 SGC 4.5 P1235
$1100.00
View Details
1995 Mike Zimmerman Signature Rookies Old Judge Autograph 1090/5750
$1.20
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 George Doggie Miller Pirates SGC 4 - VG/EX
$880.00
View Details
1995 Signature Rookie Old Judge #35 Mike Zimmerman Autograph 3680/5750 Pirates
$2.00
View Details
OLD JUDGE Cigarette Advertising CRIB BOARD Circa 1900 Goodwin & Co. NY Cribbage
$450.00
View Details
1887-1890 Old Judge REPRINT N172: DOGGIE MILLER, Pittsburgh Alleghenys/Pirates
$2.50
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Old Judge Red /99 Ralph Kiner #110 HOF
$3.98
View Details
1887-1890 Old Judge N172 REPRINT: Fred Dunlap, Pittsburgh Alleghenys (Pirates)
$2.75
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Old Judge Red /99 Nate McLouth #256 Rookie RC
$5.13
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge Mike Zimmerman Auto #35 # /5750 Pirates B4
$2.24
View Details
OLD JUDGE Cigarette Advertising CRIB BOARD Goodwin & Co. NY Cribbage Circa 1900
$375.00
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Baseball Oliver Perez “Old Judge” Autographs Auto #OP
$6.25
View Details
2005 Upper Deck #269 Ronny Paulino 2005 UD Origins Update Old Judge Red #/99
$3.99
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Old Judge Oliver Perez #157
$2.27
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins #79 Hideki Matsui OLD JUDGE Blue /50 SP New York Yankees
$9.99
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Baseball Card #184 JASON BAY Pirates OLD JUDGE Mint
$1.99
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Old Judge Red /99 Jeff Miller #234 Rookie RC
$9.74
View Details
2005 Origins Old Judge Red #234 Jeff Miller YS /99
$1.69
View Details
1986 Fritsch N172 Old Judge Reprints Art Whitney #15
$3.30
View Details
MLB MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL AUTO AUTOGRAPH AUTOGRAPHED SIGNED PICK PLAYER CARD
$2.00
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge Autograph Mike Zimmerman 5311/5750 #35 Pirates
$3.04
View Details
2005 Origins Old Judge Gold #234 Jeff Miller YS /20
$4.50
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Old Judge Blue /50 Oliver Perez #157
$8.59
View Details
2005 UD ORIGINS & OLD JUDGE VARIATION ⚾⚾ YOU CHOOSE 💎💎
$0.99
View Details
2005 Origins Old Judge Gold #184 Jason Bay YS /20
$4.50
View Details
2005 Origins Old Judge Blue #69 Craig Wilson /50
$4.50
View Details
You Pick Your Cards - Pittsburgh Pirates - MLB Baseball Team Card Selection
$12.95
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Old Judge Oliver Perez Auto #OP
$5.00
View Details
1887-1890 Old Judge N172 REPRINT: Grasshopper Jim McCormick, Pittsburgh Pirates
$3.00
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Old Judge Jason Bay #184
$2.27
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Old Judge Blue /50 Nate McLouth #256 Rookie RC
$3.41
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge MARK JOHNSON MLB Pirates AUTOGRAPH! #'d /2100
$5.99
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Old Judge Jeff Miller #234 Rookie RC
$1.40
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #298-6 Al Maul – Catch Leaning Left - PR
$550.00
View Details
TREY BEAMON - 1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge All-Stars #AS1 Autograph /2100
$3.39
View Details
2005 Origins Old Judge Blue #110 Ralph Kiner RET /50
$5.00
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge T-95 Minis Mike Zimmerman #35
$1.39
View Details
1887-1890 Old Judge N172 REPRINT: Cornelius DOYLE, San Francisco (Cal. League)
$2.50
View Details
1995 Old Judge Mini JOHN CARTER Signed Card autograph PIRATES INDIANS RC
$1.19
View Details
2005 (PIRATES) Origins Old Judge #69 Craig Wilson
$1.69
View Details
Mike Zimmerman Pittsburgh 1995 Old Judge T-96 Authentic Signature #35 1767/5750
$6.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #44-2 Tom Brown – Bat in Right Hand - PR
$495.00
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge Preview '95 /5750 Mike Zimmerman #35
$1.69
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 card of catcher Bill Farmer in catching pose
$699.00
View Details
1986 Fritsch N172 Old Judge Reprints James McCormick #37
$3.42
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge T-95 Minis Promos Trey Beamon
$2.67
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Old Judge Auto Oliver Perez #OP Auto
$7.44
View Details
Brian Giles 1996 SIGNATURE ROOKIES OLD JUDGE BASEBALL AUTOGRAPH CARD #11 RC AUTO
$12.99
View Details
2005 Upper Deck Origins Oliver Perez Old Judge Autographs #OP Pitt Pirates
$5.99
View Details
2005 Origins Old Judge Red #69 Craig Wilson /99
$3.50
View Details
1995 Old Judge Brian Giles T-96 Mini AUTO AUTOGRAPH RC /6000 INDIANS Pirates
$2.99
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge All-Stars /7500 Mark Johnson #AS4 RC
$3.42
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge MIKE ZIMMERMAN T-95 Series Auto /5750 Pirates
$3.50
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge MIKE ZIMMERMAN MLB Pirates AUTOGRAPH! #'d /5750
$5.99
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge All-Stars Signatures /2100 Mark Johnson Auto RC
$2.04
View Details
2005 Origins Old Judge Autographs Oliver Perez Auto Autograph $RARE$ PIRATES
$7.99
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies MLB Old Judge T-95 Minis Autograph #35 Mike Zimmerman
$4.95
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge Preview '95 Signatures /500 Mike Zimmerman Auto
$3.42
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge T-95 Minis Auto /5750 Mike Zimmerman #35 Auto
$1.98
View Details
Mike Zimmerman 1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge T-95 Minis Auto /5750 #35 Card
$3.00
View Details
2005 Origins Old Judge Autographs #OP Oliver Perez T3 Auto - NM-MT
$10.00
View Details
OLIVER PEREZ 2005 OLD JUDGE AUTOGRAPHS #OP Pittsburgh Pirates
$6.00
View Details
2005 Origins Old Judge Baseball - Pick your Card
$3.00
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge T-95 Minis /5750 Mike Zimmerman #35 Auto
$4.99
View Details
2004 Upper Deck Old Judge Auto Oliver Perez OP
$4.00
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge Mike Zimmerman #35
$1.35
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 George Doggie Miller Pirates PSA 3 - VG
$790.00
View Details
